KNX / ETS XML import – cannot choose target Group Address structure (imports always to root)
Area: cc/devices/knx → Import data from ETS
Problem description
In large KNX projects I regularly import only parts of the ETS Group Address structure (XML export), not the whole project.
This is intentional — importing the full ETS project every time is heavy, slow and requires a lot of re-verification.
Typical workflow:
-
In ETS I export only a fragment of Group Addresses, e.g. branch
3/2/... -
XML contains correct GroupAddress info with full GA (e.g.
3/2/0)
Example ETS XML export:
<GroupRange Name="SENSORS" RangeStart="6656" RangeEnd="6911">
<GroupAddress Name="SENSOR1" Address="3/2/0" />
</GroupRange>
Actual behavior in ComfortClick
After import:
-
All Group Addresses are placed in
devices/knxroot -
They are not imported into their logical GA structure (
3/2/...) -
There is no option to select target GroupRange / folder
-
There is no bulk move option afterwards → everything must be moved one-by-one
This is very time-consuming and error-prone in large projects.
Expected behavior
| Expected | Reason |
|---|---|
| Import into correct GA structure (3-level based on GA) | Structure is already known from ETS |
| or allow selecting target GroupRange | Partial imports are common |
| or provide bulk move after import | Basic project hygiene |
Current workaround (undesirable)
I have to manually edit the ETS-generated XML and wrap the exported fragment into a higher-level GroupRange, copied from a full ETS export:
<GroupRange Name="FLOOR" RangeStart="6144" RangeEnd="8191">
<GroupRange Name="SENSORS" RangeStart="6656" RangeEnd="6911">
<GroupAddress Name="SENSOR1" Address="3/2/0" />
</GroupRange>
</GroupRange>
This works, but:
-
requires manual XML editing
-
is error-prone
-
is extremely annoying in large / iterative projects
Question / request
Is there:
-
a setting to define import target location, or
-
a planned improvement to make ETS partial imports respect GA structure, or
-
a bulk move feature for imported KNX objects?
This would significantly improve workflows for large KNX projects.
Thanks in advance.